Skip to main content
Comparison

Last verified: October 13, 2026

Income Lab vs. Holistiplan

Income Lab is comprehensive financial planning software for financial advisors, and its tax planning runs inside the client's plan. Tax Lab (Core) models Roth conversions, IRMAA, and withdrawal sequencing from the same plan that sets the client's monthly spending and Social Security strategy. Holistiplan's tax analysis stands alone, with no retirement plan behind it.

T3 #1 by market share in T3's retirement distribution category, three years running
T3 8.60/10, top-rated Social Security All-Star (T3 2026)

Tax planning inside the plan, not beside it

Holistiplan reads a client's return and models tax scenarios. Income Lab runs tax planning inside the client's financial plan, so Roth conversions, IRMAA, and withdrawal sequencing reflect what the plan already knows. Tax Lab is included in Core at $199/month. Pro, at $299/month, adds Penny's tax tools: 1040 analysis, W-4 and NUA analysis, and the IRMAA appeal calculator.

Holistiplan's Approach

A standalone tax planning platform

"Here's what last year's 1040 shows, and the scenarios to model next."

  • OCR scanning of uploaded tax returns
  • Tax scenarios and multi-year Roth projections (Premium)
  • No retirement plan or Social Security claiming analysis
Income Lab's Approach

Tax planning inside the client's plan

"Here are the tax projections for the full length of your client's plan."

  • Tax Lab (Core) compares Roth conversion and withdrawal strategies side by side and stars the one with the highest projected net income
  • Federal, state, and local income tax for all 50 states and DC, with IRMAA on the two-year lookback, QCDs, and RMDs
  • The same plan sets the monthly spending number and evaluates 9,000+ Social Security claiming combinations for couples
  • Pro adds Penny: 1040 summaries, W-4 analysis, and the IRMAA appeal calculator

Feature comparison

Capability Income Lab Holistiplan
Plan integration
Tax analysis connected to the client's financial plan
Tax Lab runs inside the client's plan Standalone; syncs with CRM
Financial planning across the client lifecycle
Savings and accumulation planning, plan building, tax planning, Social Security, annuities, cash value life insurance, and stress testing
✓ Not included (tax, estate, and P&C insurance modules)
Social Security optimization
Social Security module rated 8.60/10 by users, the top score among T3 2026 Software All-Stars for Social Security
9,000+ claiming combinations for couples, weighted by joint survival Not included
IRMAA analysis
Medicare surcharge planning and appeal tools
Two-year lookback in Tax Lab (Core); appeal calculator with SSA-44 appeal instructions (Pro) IRMAA thresholds on Tax Report
State tax
State-level tax calculations
State and local income tax for all 50 states and DC in Tax Lab (Core) Premium tier
Medicare roadmap (Pro)
Enrollment timelines, cost estimates, IEP dates
✓ Not included
In-meeting answers (Penny)
Roth conversion, IRMAA, Medicare, and estate planning questions answered during the meeting
Penny (Pro), from the client's Income Lab data AI Assistant (beta) on tax data; no retirement plan context
Practice Intelligence (Pro)
Search across your households for Roth conversion windows, IRMAA risk, upcoming RMDs, and Medicare enrollment windows
✓ Weekly age-milestone digest (Premium)
Client data integrations
Custodian and CRM connections
Schwab, Orion, Black Diamond, Redtail, and more; Fidelity and Pershing through BridgeFT CRM and API; no custodian feeds documented
Multi-year Roth conversion analysis
Conversion projections across future years, with bracket and surcharge awareness
Strategies compared side by side across the full plan, with IRMAA bracket strategies (Core) Multi-year Roth projections with IRMAA (Premium)
W-4 withholding analysis
Federal withholding review for clients
✓ (Pro) ✓
Estate planning tools
Inherited IRAs, beneficiaries, gifting, and estate documents
Penny estate tools (Pro): beneficiary classification, inherited IRA withdrawals, multi-beneficiary allocation, gift vs. inherit Estate document review (waitlist for new customers)
Tax return analysis
Upload and analyze a client's 1040
Upload a 1040 to Penny (Pro) for a tax summary OCR scanning of uploaded returns
Starts at $199/month
Tax Lab in Core; Penny's tax tools in Pro, $299/month
From $749/year (30 households)
Annual billing only
Trial offer Free 14-day trial with full Pro access Free 7-day trial

Run both during the transition; there is nothing to cancel on day one.

What tax planning looks like inside the platform

01

Tax planning inside the client's plan

Tax Lab (Core) compares multi-year Roth conversion strategies, including IRMAA bracket strategies, with withdrawal sequencing, and stars the one with the highest projected net income. Because it runs on the plan's own data, each strategy reflects what the plan already knows about the client. Explore Tax Lab.

02

Tax work that stays with the plan

Tax Lab models federal, state, and local income tax, QCDs from IRAs, HSAs, RMDs, and IRMAA with the two-year lookback, from the plan's own data. For a one-time withdrawal, Withdrawal Optimizer (Pro) shows which accounts should fund it, what it costs in tax, and where it sits against bracket and Medicare lines. Learn about Penny.

03

Answers in the meeting

Upload a 1040 to Penny (Pro) for a tax summary in seconds. Ask a Roth conversion or IRMAA question while the client is in the room. Penny's calculations come from deterministic financial models; AI interprets the question and explains the result. Penny works from the client's Income Lab data when a plan exists. See it in action.

Common Questions

Do I need to cancel Holistiplan to start with Income Lab?

No. Run both during the transition; there is nothing to cancel on day one. Start with a free 14-day trial with full Pro access, run your next few tax conversations inside Income Lab, and decide from there.

Do I need a separate tax planning tool if I have Income Lab?

It depends on your tax work. Tax Lab (Core) models Roth conversions, bracket management, withdrawal sequencing, IRMAA, and state tax inside the plan. Pro adds Penny's 1040 analysis, W-4 analysis, and IRMAA appeal calculator.

How much does Income Lab cost?

Income Lab Core is $199/month ($1,990/year, 2 months free) and includes Tax Lab. Pro is $299/month ($2,990/year) and adds Penny's tax tools. Start with a free 14-day trial with full Pro access. Monthly billing available.

Is there a trial offer?

Yes. Start with a free 14-day trial with full Pro access, including Penny. A credit card is required; cancel before day 14 and you are not charged.

What does Holistiplan do that Income Lab doesn't?

Holistiplan offers automated client tax letters, IRS transcript retrieval, property and casualty insurance reviews, and estate document review, which its website lists as waitlist only for new customers. Income Lab does not have a dedicated estate document review module.

Why choose Income Lab over Holistiplan?

Choose Income Lab when you want tax planning inside the client's financial plan rather than in a separate tool. Tax Lab (Core) compares Roth conversion and withdrawal strategies side by side, with IRMAA bracket strategies and state tax, and the same plan gives the client a specific monthly spending number from risk-based guardrails and a Social Security strategy from 9,000+ claiming combinations for couples. Pro adds Penny's 1040 analysis, W-4 analysis, and IRMAA appeal calculator for questions in the meeting. Book a walkthrough and bring a real client scenario.

See the difference on your own client scenario

Bring a client scenario and see what Income Lab would tell that client.

Free 14-day trial with full Pro access. Credit card required; cancel before day 14 and you are not charged.

Loading available times...

Protected by Cloudflare.
Privacy Policy | Terms.

Still comparing tools?

Watch a short recorded overview of how Income Lab answers "How much can I spend?"

Watch the Overview Or see pricing
Comprehensive financial planning software. #1 by market share in retirement distribution planning, three years running (T3). Compare side by side. Book a Walkthrough See Pricing