RecordingSeptember 24, 2026 · 60 minutes · Watch on demand
One Household, Every Tax Decision: Holistic Tax Planning in Income Lab
The in-software half of a two-part September series, recorded live with audience Q&A.
Tuesday's session covered the math behind tax-smart distribution planning. This one does the work in Income Lab. Justin Fitzpatrick tests Roth conversion strategies for a hypothetical retired couple in Tax Lab, then works through the decisions a client needs made this year.
Justin split the hour in two. Strategic planning looks across the whole plan and accepts that the future is uncertain. Tactical planning prices the decision in front of the client today, where the numbers can be much more exact.
Test the conversion before recommending it
For the hypothetical couple on screen, Tax Lab found roughly $800,000 to $900,000 of combined net income and net legacy. Justin was clear that some households show no gain at all.
Hold the answer loosely
Converting to the 24% bracket beat the 22% bracket by about a quarter of a point in projected lifetime tax rate. Client appetite can reasonably decide that, and the plan gets revisited every year.
Price this year's decisions exactly
A cash request, an NUA election, an IRMAA appeal or a beneficiary split. Decisions made today can be measured precisely, and the value shows up quickly.
For educational purposes. The household is hypothetical, figures are projections from the demo rather than guarantees, and nothing here is tax or legal advice for a specific client.
Written recap, edited from the recording. The full transcript is further down the page.
Why tax planning belongs inside the plan
Justin opened with why tax planning comes up so often when advisors first look at Income Lab. It produces value a client can point to. Help someone make a good tax decision and you can save them thousands of dollars, sometimes much more over a long period, and clients already understand taxes because they have written the checks.
There are two ways to do the work. One is a specialized tax tool, which usually depends on a tax return. Justin likes tax return analysis, but a return is always a historical document: nobody has a completed 2026 return yet. The other problem is context. To plan well in a separate tool you have to recreate the plan by hand, including when Social Security starts and what it pays. Income Lab builds its tax tools into the planning app instead. His analogy: a stove is a great appliance, and it is far more useful in the kitchen than in the garage.
Get the inputs right first
Before any analysis, Justin made a garbage-in, garbage-out point. Account types need to be accurate, whether that is a traditional IRA, a SIMPLE IRA, a 401(k), a Roth 401(k) or a thrift savings plan. Settings matter too. A client who left an employer in or after the year they turned 55 may be able to take 401(k) withdrawals before 59½ without the 10% penalty, and someone still working past RMD age may be able to defer RMDs if they are not a more than 5% owner. The same goes for other income: wages and self-employment income are taxed differently, so they need to be entered as what they are.
What Tax Lab tests
The demo household was a hypothetical retired couple, 66 and 63, with a pension, rental income, a mortgage, an IRA, a 401(k) and a taxable account. Tax Lab strips the plan back to the withdrawals it needs and asks where they could come from. On screen it compared 20 approaches, with and without Roth conversions, including conversions that fill a given ordinary income bracket or stop below a Medicare IRMAA bracket, and laid the results out side by side on net income and net legacy.
Justin explained why the output is a few numbers rather than a wall of marginal-rate charts: clients respond to plain questions, such as whether a strategy produces more income or more legacy after tax. For this hypothetical couple, converting up to the 24% bracket showed roughly $800,000 to $900,000 of combined value over the plan compared with no conversions. Some advisors prefer to flip the display and present the same figure as the cost of not converting.
He was just as direct about the limits. There is not always value in this. For someone in their 70s it may be a wash, and some account mixes leave little to gain. Running the analysis is how you find out, rather than recommending conversions because they are supposed to be good.
Look for patterns, not precision
Two uncertainties sit on top of the arithmetic. Tax law, brackets and thresholds will change. And a Roth conversion trades a certain tax bill today for an uncertain benefit later, which is a trade most people dislike. Justin's advice was to look for patterns and reasonable paths rather than one perfect answer, and to treat the client's willingness to pay tax now as a real input.
The numbers on screen made the case. Converting to the 24% bracket projected a 5.96% long-term effective tax rate, against 6.23% at the 22% bracket: about 27 basis points over a 30-year plan. Stepping down to 22% also moved the couple from the fourth IRMAA bracket to the second in the conversion year, and a smaller conversion of about $100,000 was projected to keep them under IRMAA altogether. Those options carry more projected tax over time, but because IRMAA is a cliff where one dollar can cost thousands, he would discuss them rather than be dogmatic. The answer is a process: analyze, choose an approach that fits the client, revisit at least once a year.
Where the long-term value comes from
Justin named three sources, in roughly declining order. First, Roth conversions at a reasonable rate for the plan. Second, qualified charitable distributions from age 70½ for a charitably inclined client: moving money from an IRA to a Roth costs tax, while a QCD moves it to charity tax-free and keeps it out of AGI. The live QCD comparison did not load during the session, so he described the concept rather than showing the result. Third, not converting everything. Later in the plan there may be unused standard or itemized deductions, and a fully converted IRA wastes them. Because of the way RMDs work there is no precise way to size that reserve, so he suggested trying something like $100,000 to $200,000 of retained tax-deferred money.
The tactical half: the call for cash
Tactical planning is the flip side. Instead of long-range assumptions, it asks what to do today, where the answer can be more precise and the value more immediate. The classic case is the client who calls needing $100,000. To the client it is simple. To the advisor it means choosing accounts and holdings, deciding whether to offset gains with losses, avoiding a jump into a higher bracket, grossing up for tax, and handling withholding and estimated payments, possibly with the client's CPA.
On screen, Withdrawal Optimizer inside Penny took the after-tax amount and returned a recipe: shares of one holding, a sale of another at a loss used against gains, and a draw from an inherited IRA, adding up to $100,000 net, with the withholding and new estimated payments listed. Justin then showed the controls that reflect investment judgment rather than tax alone: holdings not to sell, accounts to exclude, a preferred account order, standing withholding instructions and bracket management. The report prints for the client or the CPA.
More of the tactical toolkit
Justin ran through several other tools in Penny. A tax return can be uploaded into the scenario builder to test changes, such as the couple moving to Florida, and the scenario can be sent on to the tax planning report. The Marginal Rate Explorer and the Roth conversion analysis dial in this year's numbers once actual income is clearer. His rule of thumb there: leave a gap below the line, because conversions can no longer be recharacterized. The NUA analysis compares rolling over employer stock with a net unrealized appreciation distribution, and on screen showed a net present value comparison, a timeline and a sensitivity view.
Two more stood out. For a client who has just stopped working, an IRMAA appeal can matter a great deal, because IRMAA looks back two years at MAGI. In the hypothetical on screen, where this year's MAGI was far below the MAGI from two years earlier, a successful appeal was worth about $9,200 in the current year. Whether an appeal is approved is up to Social Security. And for beneficiaries, a multi-beneficiary designation analysis showed that splitting every account 45%, 45% and 10% between two heirs and a charity would miss the intended after-tax split, because each beneficiary is taxed differently. Directing the 401(k) to the charity and assigning the other accounts deliberately hit the target, while the proportional split left about $50,000 on the table. Justin framed it as something to revisit every year or two, not something to obsess over.
Questions advisors asked, answered.
Answered on air by Justin during the session. Timestamps link into the recording.
What is net legacy net of?
Taxes paid by the beneficiaries. The default assumes heirs cash everything out immediately, so only the tax-deferred balance is taxed: taxable accounts receive a step-up in basis and Roth accounts pass tax-free. Justin takes this at 23:53.
Would letting heirs stretch inherited accounts change which strategy wins?
The dollar figures would change. The lump-sum default was chosen as the least favourable case for the heirs. When Income Lab tested allowing a stretch, the advantage of the Roth went up in the typical examples, because a Roth can be stretched too. Justin noted some cases might go the other way. See 24:28.
Should a client accept IRMAA to convert more?
It depends on the client. In the demo, the gap between converting to the 24% and the 22% bracket was small, and a smaller conversion kept the couple under IRMAA entirely. Justin would lay out those options rather than insist on the top result. The lifetime figures already account for IRMAA, which Income Lab treats as a tax. From 27:17.
How are Roth conversion taxes paid in the analysis?
First from non-portfolio income, if there is enough of it. Then from taxable accounts. Then by netting the tax out of the conversion itself. Answered at 30:10.
If the goal is family wealth, should net income and net legacy be added together?
Yes. Justin said to combine them, because no one knows how long the plan will run or exactly how the value will split between the client's lifetime and their heirs. The combined figure is the best read of what a strategy is worth. See 53:29.
How do I plan withdrawals from an inherited IRA under the 10-year rule?
Year by year. Justin showed the Marginal Rate Explorer: raise the inherited IRA distribution and see the net tax impact and where income lands against the IRMAA threshold before deciding whether an extra withdrawal is worth it. From 51:37.
Can I limit Roth conversions to certain years, such as before age 60?
Justin pointed to a setting in Advanced Plan Settings, under Taxes, that specifies the years in which Roth conversions are allowed, so you can compare results with conversions forced early or late. Justin said he wanted to think further about the trade-off itself. Answered at 56:50.
Does Withdrawal Optimizer use live custodian data?
Justin said holdings come from connected feeds where a custodian integration supplies them, while this year's investment income (interest, dividends and realized gains) comes from the plan's assumptions. So it is worth adjusting that income to where you expect the year to end up. See 57:50.
When can a client appeal IRMAA, and how does the lookback affect conversions?
Justin said an appeal needs a life-changing event such as work stoppage, work reduction, marriage, divorce, death of a spouse or loss of income-producing property. A lower MAGI on its own is not enough: skipping a Roth conversion this year after doing one two years ago does not qualify. Approval is up to Social Security, not the advisor. Because of the two-year lookback, Justin said conversions before 63 are worth more, since 63 is the first year that counts. If a life-changing event is expected, 63 itself can be clear too. Answered at 55:56 and 58:59.
Did this session carry CE credit, and are there slides?
No to both. This was a live software walkthrough with no deck and no CE credit. The CFP CE session in the series was Where the Money Comes From on September 22, where credit required live attendance.
Justin said on air that there were more questions than time. If yours was one of them, book a walkthrough and ask it directly.
New to Income Lab?
Everything in this session starts from a plan. The fastest way to see the analysis on your own numbers is to build one.
Build one plan for a real household, with accurate account types and income sources.
Open Tax Lab and compare withdrawal and conversion approaches on net income and net legacy.
Pick a range the client is comfortable with, and plan to revisit it each year.
Open Penny for this year's decisions, starting with Withdrawal Optimizer for the next cash request.
Want a one-on-one walkthrough scheduled with the team?
Justin co-founded Income Lab in 2018 to close a gap he saw across the industry: advisors lacked a way to give retirees a concrete, trustworthy answer to "how much can I spend?" He built the risk-based guardrails methodology now used by thousands of advisors, replacing probability-of-success scores with a specific spending number and dynamic adjustment rules that update automatically as conditions change.
Before Income Lab, Justin spent a decade at Jackson leading advanced planning teams and developing financial technology. He also spent seven years in academia, teaching at MIT, Harvard, Queen Mary University of London, and UCLA. He holds a PhD in Linguistics from MIT, a CFA Charter, and CFP certification.
His research and writing have appeared in Kitces.com, ThinkAdvisor, AdvisorPerspectives, and Financial Planning Magazine, and he speaks regularly at the CFP Board Research Colloquium and at NAPFA and FPA conferences.
This session did not offer continuing education credit. Withdrawal Optimizer plans and quantifies a one-time withdrawal; it does not execute trades or move money.
Go Deeper
Where this goes next.
The tools from the walkthrough, and the session that explains the math.
Searchable, skimmable, and complete. Click below to expand the full 60-minute session.
Read the full transcriptClick to expand · ~8,400 words
Okay. Hello, everyone. Welcome to our second webinar of the week on tax planning. Let everybody get in the webinar here. Take a few minutes. If you missed our CE webinar on Tuesday, that is available as a recording. Unfortunately, to get CE, you have to attend it in person.
But that is a really nice background for today, the kind of consideration, some of the math behind different things related to tax smart distribution planning. And today, we're going to be spending more time on how to do this type of planning with Income Lab. So, a couple of housekeeping items. First of all, if you have questions, please drop those in the Q&A.
If you don't see the Q&A in your menu bar there, just go to the little More menu with the three dots and a circle around it, and you should have Q&A there. I think you can usually even drag it, I remember, right, into your... I can't do it now, but sometimes you're able to drag it in to be more accessible. And if you put a question, we will try to get to it. If you see one that you like, hit the thumbs up, and we'll know that it's a question you want answered as well. I think that is all the housekeeping.
So let's dive in. All right. I want to start by talking about just tax planning as part of financial planning in general. This is probably the thing that we, as a company, hear the most interest in when we are talking with advisors who are new to Income Lab. So this is an absolutely huge part of the planning puzzle for a lot of people. And it's really understandable why, because often you can really point to real identifiable value when you do tax planning.
When you help somebody make a good tax decision, you're often saving them thousands, tens of thousands, in extreme cases or over a long period of time, hundreds of thousands of dollars. And that's real money. People are very used to paying taxes. They're used to doing their taxes. They've written those checks before, so they get it. And so it's a really great place as advisor, if this is one of your specialties or a part of what you offer, to really show clients real value. And we're going to be talking today a little bit about some new ideas or ways that you can do that that you may not have heard before.
So what is tax smart planning? Well, one place where we see this really obviously at Income Lab is because we, let's say we're talking about somebody who's retired or near retirement, we really focus on answering their questions, their normal questions, right? Not their kind of wonky, "Well, what's my probability of success?" Or something like that. We just want everyday questions that a normal person would have, even if they've never had financial planning before. So one is, well, how much can I spend? And you see here a classic Income Lab view, which is the retirement plan dashboard about what you have, what you can spend, and what would change that. So your progress.
Tax planning comes in when we start asking, okay, 13,500 a month, 12 times that per year, and a certain amount of that is coming from your investment accounts. Some of it's Social Security, could be pensions, could be all sorts of other non-portfolio sources of income. But you're going to have some withdrawals, and that might be different each month, each year. There can be all sorts of differences there. But there's a big question of where should those withdrawals come from?
And that answer might be different amounts each year, each month, and so on. When you're asking that kind of question, and we'll even ask that question about withdrawals that are not in the plan itself. So we'll talk about those sort of ad hoc or unplanned withdrawals. When somebody says, "Hey, I need $50,000 for a boat," what do you do in that situation? So there's two ways to do tax planning.
One is you can adopt specialized tax tools. And there are a lot of great tools out there, anywhere from those focused more on financial advisors to those focused more on CPAs and things. The downside of using those for financial planning is that you either have to depend on a tax return, which tax return analysis is awesome. We do it as well. But the downside of depending on a tax return is a tax return is a historical document, always. So right now, no one has a filled out complete 2026 tax return.
As far as I know, you probably can't even find the forms. So you're always basing it on history, and you can try to project that forward to this year, right? But the other is to do really good tax planning with a little more context, you have to usually imperfectly recreate the plan in that specialized software. So we have to figure out, okay, when is Social Security starting? What's the benefit going to be? Everything related to it. And so the approach that we've taken at Income Lab is to integrate these tools into a broader planning app.
The idea is there are great, you could think of it as appliances, right, or tools to have. But where they are matters. So I don't know, a stove is a great appliance. It's much more useful in the kitchen than it would be in the garage. You could cook in the garage, run back and forth, grab your pots and pans. It's just going to be a lot easier in the kitchen. And so with all of our tax planning, what we want is to bring all of that plan context in, make it immediately available with no extra work whatsoever.
So the agenda for today is, again, we're going to be talking about tax smart planning, especially tax smart distribution planning. So when I'm taking money out and if you're managing money for someone, at some point, they will want it. Where do I take the money from? We'll be talking about ways to do this in Income Lab. Roughly split this in half today. So we'll be focusing on strategic planning, meaning longer term, plan long planning, taking into context things that might happen years from now.
And then we'll be talking about tactical planning, which is about actions we might take today. And really getting value from those. So let's start here with strategic planning. Yesterday, we went over the concept behind strategic planning, tax planning, and we put up there the rule of thumb of people that you'll see out there, which is everybody should take their withdrawals first from taxable accounts, then from tax-deferred accounts, and finally from tax-free accounts.
And we went over why that became a rule of thumb. It's not based on nothing whatsoever, and it's basically in order to minimize current taxes, maximize Roth balances over time and to beneficiaries, and then tax-deferred accounts just get stuck in the middle. And we went over lots of reasons that you might not want to do that. The most obvious ones having to do with RMDs and beneficiaries receiving tax-deferred money instead of tax-free money. But we also went over how doing the actual analysis of what's better is actually very complicated. It's made complicated by the fact that there are so many interactions between different parts of the tax code, whether that's taxability of long-term cap gains, depending on how much ordinary income you have. The Social Security tax torpedo, Medicare IRMAA deduction and credit phase outs, all of these different interactions over time. So we talked about some, again, the problems with just using standard taxable, tax-deferred, tax-free.
And one of them was just the incredible complexity of the tax code. So how do we deal with that? And especially that actually is only focusing on the complexity of the tax code. It doesn't even focus on the complexity of the plan itself. So in Income Lab, you can build very realistic plans with different phasing of income sources. More withdrawals during some period, less in others, and so on. So you really have to be able to incorporate both the complexity of the tax code and the complexity of the plan itself into the analysis. So that's what Tax Lab is.
Tax Lab is a way to view all of that together, all the complexity of a plan, and all the complexity of the tax code in one place. So I'm going to go over some examples of that. But one of the outputs of Tax Lab is it's going to look at 20 different ways that you could phase withdrawals, and do Roth conversions or not. And give you a little bit of a heat map on those different solutions and see, is there green anywhere?
Is there some way that being tax smart could add to the client's good, whether that be a net income or net legacy. Before we go there, I want to just go over a little bit of Income Lab is the way we designed it is to be the defaults and things work really well for you, but you can do lots more than you initially see. So, there are two things that in order to get a really good tax analysis that we do want to get right.
One is on the account side. So you'll want to make sure that when you're building a plan, you are entering an accurate account type, whether that's traditional IRA, a simple IRA, a 401(k), a Roth 401(k), to maybe some of the less common ones, a thrift savings plan, things like that. And you'll also want to make sure that, if it's relevant, you have set some of those other settings. For example, if you have a 401(k) and somebody left that firm in or after the year they turned 55, you want to make sure to set that correctly.
The software will try to figure it out, of course, and it will kind of correct, like if you're only 53, but you try to say that you left early, you're not going to be able to do that. So we'll get that right. But you want to make those sorts of settings so that when you're doing this withdrawal analysis, if it needs withdrawals after 55, but before 59 and a half, it's got to know that, yeah, I can take withdrawals free of a 10% penalty from a 401(k) here. Same with RMD deferral settings. Less common, but if you're working past your RMD age, you can defer RMDs if you're not a more than 5% owner of the company.
So lots of little settings. The message here is just let's get the settings right, garbage in, garbage out. Same is true with the other income, the non-portfolio income. And here I'm actually going to share with you what that looks like. So if I go into... Well, maybe I'll show you here as well.
So if I want to set 401(k) values here, I've got a traditional 401(k). I want to answer, "Hey, am I still working?" If yes, then when am I going to stop working? We'll figure out if you're 55 or older at that point, right? If it's no, we'll want to say, "When did you stop?" Right? But going to the other income, we want to make sure to know, are these wages ordinary income, self-employment? Is it a pass-through business income so we can do qualified business income deductions, right? Lots of stuff to go through here.
Just make sure we're setting it right to get the values right. All right. Okay. So what we can do then with Tax Lab, let's go back to the... I have a plan here. It's the one you were just looking at, right? So here, we'll even take a look at what's in it. So this is a retired couple. You can see 66 and 63.
The actual plan already has Roth conversions in it. But part of what Tax Lab is going to do is evaluate whether that's a good idea. We've got a pension, we've got rental income. There's a mortgage still, and we basically, we have an IRA, 401(k), and a taxable account. So nothing crazy here. It looks like they're still paying their mortgage. We've got some vacations for now, short term, higher vacation spending, but nothing particularly out of the ordinary.
So now what we're going to do is analyze this in Tax Lab. And what it does is it, whether you've applied Roth conversions or not to the plan, it's going to say, "Okay, let's strip it down to kind of first principles. We know there's a certain amount we need in withdrawals. But let's look at where those withdrawals could come from, what different funding sources, whether it's Roth, IRA, 401(k), or... Yeah, look at all the ways it could go. Plus, are there any points where we could do Roth conversions?" And it's going to look at Roth conversions.
Here, I'll show it here. It's going to look at all the different ordinary and IRMAA brackets, and when possible, filling up those brackets. So if Roth conversions to fill the 0% bracket, that's really just saying, "Fill up my standard or itemized deductions," right? There's not really a 0% bracket in ordinary income. There is in long-term cap gains, but not in ordinary. Or maybe it's, "Hey, stay below IRMAA bracket one," which is, in other words, don't pay Medicare IRMAA, which is that income-related monthly adjustment amount.
It's a higher premium on parts B and D of Medicare if your income is too high, if your MAGI is too high. So it's going to just run all these. And one reason we do it that way is, A, this is the kind of... I talked at the beginning about how we wanted to speak in normal language. Okay, is there some extra income or some extra legacy net of taxes that we could produce by doing that? That's where the rubber really hits the road. The second is because of the complexity of the plan, the complexity of the tax system, showing a bunch of graphs of how marginal rates change and things, although we can do that, too, you'll see, is not the way to kind of get that through to a client. So it tends to be more about, "Hey, can we just surface a few numbers that help us understand, okay, in this case, doing Roth conversions up to the 24% bracket, compared to not doing them," which is what taxable, tax-deferred, tax-free means. Because in the background, in a Roth conversion strategy, you are actually still doing taxable, tax-deferred, tax-free.
The research out there is definitely that's the right background way to go when you're doing Roth conversions. And it looks like, okay, between net income and net legacy, we're looking at 800 or 900,000 in possible additional real value over the lifetime of this plan. So this is a better way to show to clients what we're dealing with. Sometimes advisors have told me they like to use this little back and forth arrow. All that does is flips these and presents it as a cost rather than an increase. So this is sort of saying, well, not doing Roth conversions could cost us $800,000 to $900,000 over a lifetime.
So, a good way to then step back and think about this is, okay, when there is value in this kind of tax planning, which by the way, there is not always value in this. If somebody is into their 70s, this might be a wash, not really worth it. Depending on the amounts into different types of accounts, this may not be available. So, the great thing about really just doing the work in the software is you'll figure out whether there's possibly something to squeeze out of this kind of planning. I've seen scenarios where there's not.
So that way you're not just saying, "Well, Roth conversions, I hear they're good." No, is it a good idea for you or not? And it may not be. So, where do we see the value coming from this kind of long-term strategic planning? There's sort of three places that are the largest contribution to long-term strategic planning. One is Roth conversions and finding a reasonable rate given the plan to focus on.
The other is not converting all of your tax-deferred money into Roths, and the third is retaining IRA funds for QCDs, qualified charitable distributions, at age 70 and a half and later. So we're going to go over those. However, I do want to, before we do that, bring up a really important kind of, I don't know, methodological point I guess. Which is, another problem with tax planning of this sort is there's both uncertainty about the future in terms of what tax rates will be in the future. The whole tax system could change.
Certainly thresholds and brackets could change. They've changed in the past, as this is showing. They'll probably change in the future. And there's also a trade-off when you're doing Roth conversions where you're exchanging a certain loss today, meaning you're going to pay taxes on the Roth conversion, for an uncertain gain in the future. And that's not the type of thing that humans love. And so although we're going to go through examples and look at numbers and things, the appropriate way to approach this is not fixating on precision, not trying to find a one perfect answer, but rather looking for patterns and trends and reasonable ways forward, including, by the way, a client's willingness and ability to do this. So you might find a solution that says Roth convert to the 24% bracket, like you see here, but that's just not possible because the client's not really willing to pay that kind of tax up front. Maybe they can articulate why, maybe they can't.
And so we need to work within the real world. So for example, this example, we're predicting 5.96% effective long-term rate in taxes at 24% bracket. 22 is at 6.23. Okay, 20 some bips in difference over time, over a 30-year plan or something, that's not anything to write home about. It's even going lower, where long-term rate might be seven or nine. Nobody knows what tax rates will be in the future.
Nobody knows what returns will actually be. So all of this is a projection. It's a useful way to do the analysis, but we need to have a little bit of humility around it. The other thing is helping clients understand that this is not a single answer, it's a process. So we're going to analyze a long-term plan today. We're going to choose an approach that works based on not just the numbers, but on client appetite and attitude. And then we're going to revisit this at least annually. And it might change, because any of these things may have changed.
All right. With those caveats, let's go back to here. All right. So, here we have that first step. I said it's sort of diminishing return. So the first big step is Roth conversions, where we might gain some values. I do see a few questions here that maybe I can hit quickly. So [attendee] is asking, "What is net legacy net of?" Great question. It's net of taxes paid by the beneficiaries.
And here it assumes that the beneficiaries cash everything out immediately. So the only thing taxed would be the tax deferred balance. So taxable accounts get a step-up in basis. Roth accounts are received tax-free. So it's only the tax deferred accounts where ordinary income is due, and we just figure out the taxes due on that. We had a really interesting question that an advisor asked us the other day, which was, "Hey, would you get a different net legacy if you allowed the beneficiary to stretch the Roth and the inherited IRAs and 401(k)s and things?" Of course, the numbers would be different clearly, right? But would you get a different ranking?
Would suddenly Roth conversions look better or worse, right, for example. And so we did a little research on that. I thought it was great. We made this decision to use the lump sum as a default because it's sort of the "worst thing" a client could, a beneficiary could do. So we wanted to sort of stack the deck against them. And it does turn out actually that if you allowed stretch, the advantage of having a Roth goes up. So at least in some examples. There may be some examples where it goes the opposite way.
But in kind of typical examples that we ran, because you can stretch both, right? You can stretch a Roth or you can stretch an IRA. So, that was interesting. But yeah, this is a lump sum assumption. Let's see if there's a few others. "Can you adjust the long-term cap gain assumptions?" You can. It is not directly in here.
I guess I'll address that right here. So there are, in any kind of strategic plan, which is long-term plan, you're going to need some assumptions about how much turnover and dividends and things like that are happening each year. Will that be accurate for 10 years from now? No, not a chance, right? But you have to have an assumption. When you're doing a this year analysis, which we'll get to in a second, then clearly you're going to want to dial it in a little bit more to be close to what you think this year really will end up as. But if you're setting the long-term assumptions in your plan, you want to go to settings, default values, and... Oh, I'm not even. Okay. I would need to log in as a different type of user.
But there is a... I'm sorry. I can maybe do that later. There is a setting if I were logged in as a different type of user where it's asset class taxes, and there you can set the assumptions around how much of the gain each year is realized long-term and short-term capital gains and dividends and things like that. So great question. Great question, [attendee], on IRMAA. So, for example, here we're at the 24% bracket, and you can see that pushes them for this year way into the IRMAA brackets.
And whether or not, this is my point about let's not get anchored to a particular answer, because if a client just has a certain appetite for paying taxes and a certain appetite for not, that may be determinate. The difference between, in this case, a 24% bracket, and a 22% bracket, we can see is less than 1%, right?
And so if I switch this to... So I'm not going to get hung up on that. It looks like in the analysis, yeah, you're paying a lot more taxes over time, or not a lot more. You're paying more over time if you do the 24% bracket, 22 versus 24. But, hey, we don't know the future, so let's be a little bit humble. If I switch it to 22, I've now taken them out of IRMAA bracket four, brought them down to IRMAA bracket two. Now, you might even say, "Well, is there a way we could pay no IRMAA at all?" Yeah, there absolutely is.
Of course, we're projecting. If this projection goes exactly as it says, then you'll therefore pay more taxes over time. But we don't know that for sure, and there is a way to still do some conversions, looks like about $100,000 this year, and project you to stay under IRMAA. So I would be... Depends on the situation, of course. There are some where there's no way they can stay out of IRMAA. But just discuss those options. I wouldn't be dogmatic about it if somebody is just really not loving the idea of IRMAA, which I do get, because it's a cliff tax where $1 costs you thousands of dollars. So that would be my approach.
I think it's a great question. I'd love to hear from other people what their experience is with that. Does the tax savings over my lifetime net out the IRMAA? Yes, it does. So this is... We, in the Income Lab, IRMAA just is a tax. You'll see it in the tax tables wherever you see it. I know technically it's a premium increase, but we just treat it as a tax. We put it in there. Let's see here. Okay. Yeah. A few more good questions that I might hit in the other section.
How are Roth conversion taxes paid? They're first paid by outside income, so if you have enough non-portfolio income. Then they're paid from taxable accounts, then they're paid from netting out the conversion itself. Okay. Maybe I'll kind of close on this point, and then we'll move to the tactical stuff, which addresses a few of the other questions. But I said there's sort of three things that can help here. I'm going to move us back to the 24% bracket, which is the "best one." I can also add qualified charitable distributions.
So moving money from an IRA, for example, to a Roth costs you money because there's a tax situation. Getting money out of an IRA through a qualified charitable distribution, which is a direct transfer to a charity, is tax-free, and it doesn't even hit your... What the heck happened here? I might have to rerun this one. And it doesn't even hit your AGI. So really, it's the best way to do things, and I had this set up earlier. Thought it was...
Maybe it was a different plan. Let me see. I got to make sure these plans are identical. So getting money out of an IRA without paying taxes is clearly better. It'll depend on the... Yeah. Sorry, I must have lost this plan. So I'll just say, the concept is sound. The amount of charitable inclination that you have has a big part to do in this. So if you have a lot of charitable inclination, and you can, once you hit 70 and a half, move money out of an IRA, the maximum each year is, I think, around 100,000. A little more than that now.
That's even better. So I said, okay, it's a diminishing return where QCDs are sort of a second chunk, and they're typically less because most people aren't giving at the max. If you were, for some reason, then it can really be a huge part of it. The last piece is you typically don't want to fully convert your IRA or 401(k). The reason is, later in the plan, you may end up with unused deductions, standard deductions, itemized deductions, and so on.
And so that's not the most efficient way to get money out. Unfortunately, there is no way to sort of determine ahead of time the exact right dollar amount to withhold, to not convert. Certainly, you don't want to convert if you're going to do QCDs, and Income Lab will automatically figure out how much not to convert. But in terms of keeping some money around for low future taxes, 0% tax, 10% tax, there is no way to do it because of the way RMDs work. So typically, you might just try $100,000, $200,000 in retained tax-deferred balances.
All right, so those are the three kind of places we find long-term value typically. Just in the last 20 minutes here before I hit some questions, I want to... Because some of these questions especially have to do with tactical tax smart distribution planning. Which is, it's the flip side of that, okay, we're doing long-term planning. We've got to make a bunch of assumptions. We've got to handle all the interactions. But we're also simultaneously aware that we don't know what things will be like in 10 years, 20 years, and so we're making the best assumptions we can and just going forward with strategy with that. With tactical situations, it's about what do we do today, and there we can typically be a lot more precise, and we can also show a lot more immediate value.
So a classic one is, and this is a new tool that we just put out, is I need some money now. This is even money outside of the plan. So we didn't have a plan to spend an extra 50,000 this year, but we look at it, and we can afford it, and if we're going to do it, where do we take the money from? So that's the Withdrawal Optimizer. I'm going to go through a few other tools that are really helpful, including in this question about the 10-year rule that [attendee] has, and so on. I guess maybe... Well, yeah, I'll try to hit these a little bit.
[attendee], good question. Can we use historical tax rates? We don't have a tool to do that. That would be cool. I like that. Okay, so let's jump into these tools one by one, and I'll kind of show you how to use them. Okay, so all of these tools are in Penny, which is available...
There's a couple places. You can either access it from the app launcher right here, or you can access it if you're working on a plan. You'll find a little Penny icon here in the upper left, and this will just shoot you right into Penny in that chosen household. This is a slightly different environment. I've got some new things in here that you don't have yet, but soon you'll have an education and a retirement section. But we're looking at the Withdrawal Optimizer. So this is absolutely huge. And talking with advisors, this is a super common task.
The client thinks it's easy, but it's not. So they call up, they want some money. Understandably, right? It's their money. Maybe they can afford this. I need $100,000. But you immediately have all these questions. Okay, well, where do I take it from? What holdings do I sell? What don't I sell? Should I do... Should I offset with losses? Are there considerations around not tripping into new tax brackets? It's a huge issue. How much do I gross up for taxes? If I gross up, how do I handle withholding and estimated taxes and so on?
It's probably something, if it's a bigger one, you might want to coordinate with the CPA. How do I communicate with that advisor? So that's what this plan is all about. By default, you just throw in the after-tax amount needed. If for some reason you already know that, you can just go to a gross withdrawal. But cash in hand, you can decide, do I want to cover all the tax? Do I want to do a safe harbor? Which just means I'm going to owe more tax in next year, but for now, I'm not going to pay it all, but I also don't want to pay penalties. But by default, you're covering everything. And then immediately you get a...
Oh, looks like I already have a few things applied here, but you're going to get a recipe. You're going to say, okay, this much Apple, this much Citigroup, which gives me a loss. You can see I'm even going to be able to use some of that loss against some gains, and I'm taking from the inherited IRA. Altogether, I'm going to net out my 100,000. A certain amount is going to be withheld, and I've got some new estimated payments to make. So boom, it points it out. It even points out, hey, in this plan, there's actually a cash value life insurance policy. This was me. I called it...
It was originally a term policy. I switched it to a permanent. So, that's just the name. I could've called that John's Insurance. And it's going to point all that out. So this is awesome. I can do a print. I could get the withdrawal recipe. I could throw in any other pieces of this report that I want, and now I have it, and I can share it with a CPA or the client or so on. There's also, like I said, there's a lot I can do. So, it's not all about taxes. Obviously, some is about the investments, right? So maybe I don't want to sell any of this.
Maybe I only want to sell a little bit of Apple, if I need to sell any at all. Maybe I don't even want to include certain accounts. Maybe I want to decide which accounts are more important in taking money out of, which ones I'm more willing to take money out of. I could add an account order here, right? I could say, "No, I want to take out Mary's account first, please." And when I do that, I now have taken money out of Mary's account first, right? Turn that back off.
I can set up my standing orders on withholding, and I can decide whether I want to change those or not. Maybe if it's a small one, it's not worth the administrative effort. I can set bracket management. For example, here, I'm trying to keep my MAGI low. Unfortunately, this plan has no Roths, so I can't do it. But if I had a Roth account, it would... You could see my MAGI is higher than IRMAA, the IRMAA bracket, and so it would take that out.
So this is a really valuable tool for those kind of tactical tax planning. It's one of the top requests we've had from people, and it's one of the most successful tool launches that we've had. All right. I want to share a few general tools that not everybody's aware of if you're just doing more, like, tax analysis. First of all, you can always upload a tax return in Penny.
Like I said, I actually really love tax return analysis. It's just important to understand that it is a historical document. So you could pull in a tax return here in our scenario builder, which is this incredible tool for doing in-depth analysis on possible changes you might make. So, for example, here I have the base plan, and I have them moving to Florida, and I want to know how much are they going to save if they do that. There's places throughout here where this can be a real useful way for you to keep some notes for yourself. Maybe it's right here, I'm going to say, "May buy New Jersey munis" or something next to the tax-exempt interest. Maybe I want to figure out what their W2 wages are and really break it down by different types of income.
Maybe I want to annualize their earnings. There's just a ton of cool tools here, and these all save, so you'll have them when you come back into the tool. And if you want to launch a scenario in one of the other tools, you can, right? So you can move right to the tax planning report where they have moved to Florida, right? So really great tool. I'd encourage you to check it out if you're doing more in-depth tax analysis. The marginal rate explorer and the Roth conversion analysis are similar things.
So somebody was asking, "Okay, what if I'm doing a Roth conversion this year? Yeah, my long-term strategic plan has me doing a certain amount, but now I'm getting close to a place where I know what my income for this year might look like, right?" So maybe I can check. Okay, you know what? We thought we'd have all these cap gains, but we really haven't sold that much this year, and it's only going to be 10,000. Okay, well, that changes things, right? So we're dialing in the withdrawal amount for this year and able to then, again, print this, share it with the CPA, memorialize it, right? What was the thinking? What were the inputs here?
And why would this be the number? With Roth conversions, I usually say you should leave a little gap, right? Because you can't recharacterize things like you used to be able to. So, you're better off not taking over that line. All right. Couple others that I want to go over before we get too late here. One is NUA analysis, net unrealized appreciation. So again, this is one of those tactical things. Somebody's leaving a job. They're considering, should I roll over the company stock that I received in my ESOP or whatever, or should I do an NUA, a net unrealized appreciation distribution?
So just a simple matter of getting the fair market value, the cost basis, making a few assumptions, and immediately you get a net present value analysis. In this case, it shows that NUA is probably better off. So if you want, you can open Ask Penny and ask why, what sorts of things are helping me here? It's going to talk about the fact that NUA is not subject to net investment income tax.
You're going to get a timeline for when these things have to happen, lump sum distribution, paying the tax on the cost basis in different years, and so on. And again, option to print this out, and so on. There's also a way to say, hey, what's the sensitivity of this analysis to the different assumptions? So I can look at, well, it depends a little bit on how quickly the stock grows and so on. Two more I want to hit quickly, and then we'll get some questions.
We talked about Medicare IRMAA, and someone was asking, "Hey, if the Roth analysis says maybe it's worth paying some IRMAA, but the client's really against it, what can we do?" And my answer was, "Well, hey, if it's not too much smaller of a Roth conversion, maybe we lean into it, if the difference isn't huge." Because client's ability and willingness to spend money on Roth conversions is an important input. There's another thing, though, which is early in retirement, if somebody has just left employment, you can apply for an IRMAA appeal.
And this is not a place where the person considering the appeal has to use their judgment. If you had a work stoppage, retirement, or job loss, you'll get it. So, now this tool can't guarantee you'll get it because we don't know if this is really true. But if you have the evidence that this has happened, then you're definitely in a good position. So, for example, if in this case, our MAGI this year is a lot lower than our MAGI two years ago because IRMAA does a two-year look back at your MAGI, and we get this appeal done, we're going to save 9,200 bucks this year, which is actually huge.
You can, again, print this out, give some instructions on who to call, where to go. It's not up to you, not up to us whether it gets approved, but if they have the evidence for it, this will happen. So, this one is actually huge, especially to get people right in that retirement year. All right. The last one actually does have to do with somebody was asking about beneficiary planning. And just to step back and talk about that strategically, you're right that it's one of the...
That also added to this, let's be a little bit more humble about what the exact right thing to do is because no one knows when they're going to die, and beneficiary considerations may be high on the list, might be low on the list, and so on. So we have a bunch of these tools that will help us figure out, well, A, what kind of beneficiary are you, therefore, what kinds of options do you have under SECURE Act to distribute? If you're a single beneficiary, maybe you're getting a $200,000 IRA.
Let's look at what's my optimal way to receive, in this case, basically the RMD minimum, which means in the first nine years, I have to take life expectancy RMDs, and in the 10th year, I have to take the rest out. That looks like the best net present value for my inheritance. So this, the one I just did, that's when somebody inherits, that's when you would use it. The multi-beneficiary optimizer, I want to actually spend a little time on because I don't think this is something that's commonly done, where on a regular basis, maybe annually, maybe every couple of years, you want to figure out how to properly set the beneficiaries. So maybe we have John, and he's single. We have Mary, who, let's say, she makes a lot more money, and is married filing jointly. Maybe we've got the United Way.
It's a charity. And I want them to split. I want 10% to go to the United Way and 45% and 45%. All right. A proportional split where every single account goes 45%, 45%, 10% misses the target. It doesn't actually split the net of tax benefit 45%, 45%, 10% because of the difference in taxation on these individuals, and it actually leaves a little money on the table, so about $50,000.
So optimal designations are going to be a little bit different. So here I'll change maybe just to keep it clear, since John is one of the clients, and we've got Mark and Mary. So we can see because of these differences, we are not going to do straightforward. United Way is going to get all of its money from the 401(k). We're going to split the other things sort of equally. Mark's going to get the taxable account, and so on.
And then we'll see down at the bottom here why a proportional split would not have been right. So it would've ended up with the United Way getting more than its intended share. So again, this isn't something we need to obsess about because hopefully no one's dying in the next year or two, but it is done with today's dollars because that's what it's about. We're not going to set it for 30 years from now. Instead, every few years, every year, maybe we'll do this analysis and see how far off we are. So it's a way to distribute the money in a tax-smart way.
All right. Just a few minutes left, so I want to see if we have some questions. Okay, so [attendee] mentions that all that Roth stuff also has to do with optimal distributions from inherited IRAs subject to the 10-year rule. That's a really good point, [attendee], and actually those tools for the withdrawals or for actually probably the marginal rate explorer would be the place I would go to do that. So again, it's about year-by-year stuff.
So I'm going to go to Taxes, Marginal Rate Explorer, and now what I'll do is I'll go in here, and change my taxable IRA distribution. So if I say, all right, I'm right here. I'm at 180,000. My IRMAA is at 218. So maybe I just want to take some extra. I can actually just click on this, and it'll tell me. I didn't click it there.
I got to 217. And it'll show me everything that's going to happen. If I take those extra withdrawals from my inherited IRA this year, it's going to have this net tax impact, so an extra 8,700. So that's one way that I would do that and sort of see if that's worthwhile. I think what you're suggesting is, wouldn't it be cool if we had an inherited IRA optimizer? That's a great idea. We do not yet have that, but we do have the tactical tool for getting there.
All right. If the goal is to maximize family wealth, should we be adding total net income and total net legacy? Yes. That's a really great question. So there's how do I really understand the net possible value of a strategy to the client and their beneficiaries? What I say is combine these two in your head, because again, we don't know if this is a 20, 30 year plan. Is it really going to be that 546 if it goes to in their lifetime and 329 goes at death? Probably not, right?
So what this is saying is combined, that's the combined net impact. Will it shake out to exactly that split between beneficiaries and people alive today? Who knows, right? It's extremely unlikely you live exactly as long as this plan says you will, and so on. So yeah, that's exactly the right way to think about it is the combination of those two things. All right. Let's see.
Do you expect to have an integration with Altruist for individual stock holdings? [attendee], yes, we do. So we're slowly rolling out because for things like the withdrawal optimizer, to get the holdings into the actual recipe, you need to have holdings in the plan, and so we're rolling out slowly. Now we have Schwab, I believe we have Redtail, Orion. So we're expanding our integrations to handle more of the holdings.
In the marginal tax rate estimator, there's a way to show state tax thresholds. There's not yet, but it is on our list to add to it because clearly that would be very helpful, [attendee]. I appreciate the question. Next in-person workshop, I do not know for sure, but we definitely will be having one. That's the Income Lab Academy, which people really love coming to. We've had them in a few different parts of the country. So be on the lookout for announcements there. "Since IRMAA is a two-year combined look-back, bunching conversions in one year would not be effective." [attendee question, read aloud] I mean, obviously, it depends on the amount of conversion you're talking about, but it certainly does say, hey, conversions before you turn 63 are worth a lot more because 63 is that first year.
Unless you know that you will be having a qualifying life event in that period, right? So if you're able to reset because of one of these life-changing events, marriage, divorce, death of a spouse, work stoppage, work reduction, loss of income-producing property, then actually 63 is free and clear. So that's a really good thing to be on the lookout for. [attendee], I do believe we could do that trade-off.
We probably don't have enough time to show you, but you're asking about the trade-off between kind of forcing Roth conversions to be before age 60. Maybe they're still working, maybe they're paying out of pocket and so on, or later. One tool you can use that I think would be helpful for that is you can go to the Advanced Plan Settings, go to the Taxes section, and hit Specify years when Roth conversions are allowed, and then you can decide which years you want to do. So maybe you want to force them to be only in the first three years before you turn age 60 or something, right?
Or maybe you want to force them to be only after. So I think that's going to be one of the ways that you would want to do that. But I'm going to have to think about it a little bit more. It's a good question. Are the withdrawal plan calculations based on live portfolio feeds from connected custodians? Not yet. It's a really good question. So they are based on live feeds for holdings, absolutely. What is not yet here, because we would have to have every single piece, is the investment income. So these numbers, interest, tax-exempt interest, qualified dividends, non-qualified, short-term, long-term capital gains, all of that is from the plan, which is based on the assumptions in the plan. So you'll want to go in and say, okay, well, where do I really think this year is going to end up? If we had 100% coverage through custodians and we could look at, okay, what have we had so far, and you could pull that in here, that would be awesome, and we probably will do that at some point and just make it really clear, hey, you're pulling it in, but you're only pulling it in from these.
If they have outside sources of this kind of income, this number is not going to be accurate. But yeah, that would be a nice little way to make this even easier. Why is the IRMAA thing appealable? Yeah, let's go back to that. So there are only a few reasons to do it, [attendee]. So yeah, it's not just that my MAGI this year is a lot lower. Of course, you would want to appeal if it's higher [caption unclear; context suggests "wouldn't"], right? So you'd only appeal if it's lower.
But it can't just be, well, it was high in 2024 because I did a Roth conversion, and this year I didn't do a Roth conversion. That would be great if you could do that, but it actually has to be because of one of these qualifying life events. Yeah. All right. Unfortunately, a bunch more questions I didn't get to, but that is our hour. Definitely let us know if you want to see more. If you want to look more at Penny, our team is available for demos and things like that.
So please check us out and book some time with us. But thank you, everybody, for coming. Really appreciate it, and I hope to see you at our next webinar. Take care.
Machine transcribed from the recording and lightly corrected. Attendee names are replaced with [attendee]. Where the wording matters, the recording is the source.