Back to Resources

Advisor Summary: A Roth conversion moves pre-tax IRA money into a Roth IRA, paying income tax now to eliminate future taxes on growth and withdrawals. A strong strategy converts a specific amount each year during the gap between retirement and RMDs at age 73 or 75, filling lower tax brackets while staying below IRMAA thresholds. With TCJA rates now permanent under OBBBA, the case rests on bracket management, RMD compression, and a new temporary senior deduction that creates hidden effective rate increases between $150K and $250K MAGI for married couples.

Your client is 62, just retired, and sitting on $1.2M in a traditional IRA. They won’t take Social Security until 67. They have no earned income.

For the next five years, their taxable income is essentially zero.

This is the Roth conversion window. For many retirees with large pre-tax balances, it is one of the most valuable tax planning opportunities they will have. The question for this client is usually not whether to convert. It’s how much, in which years, and how to avoid triggering costs that eat into the benefit, including, for clients who buy Marketplace health coverage, the effect on their premium tax credit.

This guide covers the full strategy: when the window opens, how to size conversions year by year, how to avoid IRMAA surprises, and how to present the multi-year plan to clients in a way that builds confidence and drives action.

How a Roth Conversion Works

A Roth conversion moves money from a pre-tax retirement account (traditional IRA, 401(k), 403(b)) into a Roth IRA. You pay income tax on the converted amount now; in return, the money grows tax-free and qualified withdrawals are never taxed again. There is no annual limit on conversion amounts, and no income restriction (unlike Roth IRA contributions, which phase out at $242,000-$252,000 MAGI for married couples in 2026).

The math is simple: pay tax now at a known rate to eliminate tax later at an unknown rate.

The 2026 landscape: what changed

The One Big Beautiful Bill Act (OBBBA), signed July 4, 2025, permanently extended the TCJA tax rate structure. The 10/12/22/24/32/35/37% brackets are no longer scheduled to sunset.

What this means for advisors: The “convert now before rates go up in 2026” urgency narrative is gone. Tax rates at the federal level are staying where they are. But that doesn’t make Roth conversions less valuable. It shifts the conversation from “rates are going up” to three stronger arguments:

  1. Your client’s personal rate may go up. For clients with large pre-tax balances, RMDs at 73 (or 75 for those born 1960 or later) can push income into higher brackets whether federal rates change or not, and a surviving spouse filing single faces narrower brackets.
  2. The new OBBBA senior deduction creates a hidden planning wrinkle that raises the effective marginal rate by about 1.3 to 2.9 percentage points in its phaseout range (more on this below), but it also increases the size of the “0% bracket” for the next few years.
  3. Tax-free compounding adds value under the right conditions. It helps when the tax is paid from money outside the IRA, or when today’s rate is lower than the rate the money would face later. If the rate is the same now and later and the tax comes out of the IRA, a conversion roughly breaks even: at 22% both times and 7% growth for 25 years, $100,000 left pre-tax is worth $423,340 after tax, and the $78,000 that reaches the Roth grows to the same $423,340. Hypothetical example: $100,000 converted with the tax paid from outside funds grows to $542,743 in the Roth at 7% a year for 25 years.

Key rules every advisor should know

  • No annual limit on how much you can convert. Unlike Roth IRA contributions ($7,500 for 2026, or $8,600 at age 50 and older), conversions have no dollar cap.
  • Conversions are irrevocable. Once converted, you cannot undo it.
  • The 5-year rule: If the Roth owner is under age 59.5, each conversion has its own 5-year clock for withdrawals of the converted funds to be free from a 10% penalty. (The 5-year rule blocks investors from using Roth conversions as a way to get funds out of traditional retirement accounts penalty free.) For clients over 59.5, the early withdrawal penalty rule is moot. A separate 5-year rule governs tax-free earnings: earnings are not tax-free until a 5-year period has passed, starting January 1 of the first tax year for which the client funded any Roth IRA, by contribution or conversion. This is a good reason to open a small Roth as soon as reasonable.
  • The pro-rata rule: You can’t cherry-pick which dollars to convert. See the worked example below.
  • RMDs come first. Once RMDs begin, take the year’s RMD first. The RMD itself cannot be converted; only amounts above it can.
  • Backdoor Roth is still permitted. OBBBA did not restrict nondeductible contributions followed by conversion.

The pro-rata rule: a worked example

All traditional, SEP, and SIMPLE IRA balances are aggregated by the IRS. The formula uses the December 31 balance of all traditional, SEP and SIMPLE IRAs, plus any amounts converted or withdrawn during the year.

Scenario: Your client has a $300,000 traditional IRA (all pre-tax) and a $50,000 traditional IRA from nondeductible contributions (after-tax basis of $50,000). They want to convert $100,000.

  • Total traditional IRA balance for the formula: $250,000 at year end plus the $100,000 converted = $350,000 (assuming no growth during the year)
  • After-tax basis: $50,000
  • Tax-free percentage: $50,000 / $350,000 = 14.3%
  • Of the $100,000 conversion: $14,286 is tax-free, $85,714 is taxable

They can’t just convert the $50,000 after-tax IRA and pay zero tax. The IRS treats it as one pool.

Advisor takeaway: If a client has significant after-tax IRA basis and wants to maximize tax-free conversion, explore rolling the pre-tax portion into a current employer’s 401(k) first. This removes pre-tax money from the aggregation, allowing the after-tax IRA to be converted with minimal tax. Complete the roll-in by December 31 of the conversion year, because the formula uses year-end balances.

When to Do a Roth Conversion: The Retirement Gap Window

For many clients, the best time to do a Roth conversion is during the years between retirement and the start of Required Minimum Distributions (age 73 for those born 1951-1959, age 75 for those born 1960+), when taxable income is at its lowest and the most bracket space is available.

For clients born in 1960 or later who retire between 62 and 67, this gap is roughly 8 to 13 years. During this window:

  • Earned income is gone or reduced
  • Social Security may not have started yet
  • RMDs haven’t kicked in
  • The client is often in the lowest tax brackets they will see in retirement

A common mistake: waiting too long. Once RMDs start, they can push the client into higher brackets, and the conversion window effectively closes. Every year that passes without conversions is bracket space permanently lost.

Three client scenarios

Scenario A: A recently retired couple with a large IRA

  • Married filing jointly, ages 63 and 62 in 2026, both recently retired
  • $1.4M in traditional IRAs, $200K taxable, $300K Roth
  • Social Security: $48,000/year combined, both claiming in 2030 (ages 67 and 66)
  • No pension, no earned income

Illustration assumptions: All figures are in 2026 dollars. Tax brackets, the standard deduction and Social Security benefits are assumed to rise with inflation, so 2026 IRS levels apply in every year. The IRAs grow 3% a year above inflation. Conversion taxes and living costs are paid from outside the traditional IRAs, and income on the taxable account is ignored. Living costs before 2030 and the conversion tax are paid from the taxable account and, once it runs low, from the Roth IRA; drawing on the Roth reduces the benefit of converting. Tax figures are federal income tax only. The extra standard deduction at 65 and the 2028 senior deduction are included. RMDs use the combined IRA balance and the age-75 divisor of 24.6.

Conversion window: 12 years (2026 through 2037, older spouse ages 63-74) before RMDs at 75, because both spouses were born after 1959.
Without conversions: The couple owes no federal income tax for 12 years, and that bracket space is lost. The IRAs grow to about $1,996,000, so the first RMD is about $81,100. With 85% of Social Security taxable ($40,800), taxable income is about $86,400, in the 12% bracket. RMDs then rise each year as the divisor shrinks. A surviving spouse filing single with the same RMD would be in the 22% bracket even before Social Security, because the single 12% bracket ends at $50,400 of taxable income.
Suggested strategy: Convert $100,000 a year from 2026 through 2037. Before Social Security starts, that uses most of the 12% bracket (taxable income of $60,150 to $67,800). Once Social Security starts, the same conversion makes 85% of benefits taxable and reaches $4,500 into the 22% bracket (taxable income of $105,300). Federal tax on the conversions totals about $130,000 on $1.2M converted, an average rate of about 10.8%. The first RMD falls to about $21,700. MAGI peaks at $140,800, well under the $218,000 joint IRMAA threshold.
Health coverage before 65: If the couple buys Marketplace coverage in 2026 and 2027 (and the younger spouse until turning 65), a $100,000 conversion puts household MAGI at $100,000. For 2026 coverage, a two-person household above 400% of the federal poverty line (4 x $21,150 = $84,600) gets no premium tax credit, and any advance credit must be repaid in full. The 10.8% average above does not include that cost. Compare the lost credit with the tax saved, or keep MAGI under the limit until Medicare starts.
What it is worth: The conversions tend to pay off when the converted dollars would otherwise be taxed above that 10.8% average (12% on RMDs at first, 22% for a surviving spouse, plus any IRMAA surcharges), by enough to cover any premium tax credit the conversions cost before 65. The lifetime dollar benefit depends on growth, inflation, life expectancy and future tax law, so compare total lifetime taxes with and without conversions in a projection.

Scenario B: The single high earner

Hypothetical illustration at 2026 tax levels; not a recommendation for any client.

  • Age 66, recently retired
  • $650,000 traditional IRA, $150K taxable, $100K Roth
  • Social Security at 70: $38,000/year
  • Small pension: $12,000/year

Conversion window: 9 years (ages 66-74) before RMDs at 75 for a client born in 1960 (a client born in 1959 starts RMDs at 73, which leaves 6 years). Shorter window, but the pension eats bracket space.
Key constraint: The $12,000 pension plus standard deduction ($18,150 for single 65+) leaves less room in lower brackets. Through 2028 the client also gets the $6,000 senior deduction, which phases out at 6% of MAGI above $75,000 (at $77,000 of MAGI it is $6,000 minus 6% of $2,000, or $5,880).
Suggested strategy: Convert $50,000-$65,000/year, staying within the 22% bracket ($105,700 for single filers). IRMAA threshold for single filers is $109,000; this client must be careful not to breach it.

Scenario C: The high-net-worth early retiree

Hypothetical illustration at 2026 tax levels; not a recommendation for any client.

  • Ages 58 and 56, both retired (tech industry)
  • $3.2M in traditional IRAs/401(k), $800K taxable, $400K Roth
  • No Social Security for 9+ years, no pension

Conversion window: 17-19 years before RMDs at 75. Longest window, largest IRA.
Challenge: The sheer size of the traditional balance. Even aggressive conversions up to certain brackets won’t eliminate RMDs entirely.
Suggested strategy: Convert $150,000-$200,000/year, filling into the 22% bracket (which ends at $211,400 of taxable income MFJ in 2026; the 24% bracket runs to $403,550). Under 59.5, so the 5-year penalty rule applies to converted amounts, but the couple can fund living expenses from the $800K taxable account. Over 15 years, this converts $2.25-$3M to Roth, dramatically reducing future RMDs.
Watch: Before 65, conversions that lift household MAGI above 400% of the federal poverty line ($84,600 for two people for 2026 coverage) end the ACA premium tax credit for that year, and any advance credit must be repaid in full. From age 63, each year’s conversion plus investment income sets Medicare premiums two years later, so check it against the IRMAA thresholds ($218,000 joint in 2026).

Advisor takeaway: The conversion amount is different for every client. Single vs. married, pension vs. no pension, early retiree vs. late retiree. The variables are the gap length, existing income that fills brackets, and the IRMAA/senior deduction thresholds. There is no universal “right amount.”

How to Determine the Right Conversion Amount Per Year

A common starting point is to fill the current tax bracket to its upper limit without spilling into the next bracket or, for clients 63 and older, crossing an IRMAA threshold. The best amount depends on the client’s full conversion window. For a married couple under 65 with no other income in 2026, the conversion capacity in the 12% bracket alone is approximately $133,000.

Several factors make the calculation complex:

  1. Current year income: W-2, 1099, pension, or Social Security occupies bracket space first
  2. State taxes: California (13.3% top rate) vs. Texas or Florida (0%) changes the optimal amount
  3. IRMAA brackets: Medicare surcharges are based on MAGI from two years prior
  4. Capital gains interaction: Large conversions can push capital gains from 0% to 15%+
  5. The OBBBA senior deduction phaseout (new for 2025-2028)

The bracket-filling approach

Start with the 2026 standard deduction: $32,200 for married filing jointly ($35,500 with both spouses 65+, adding $1,650 each). This is tax-free income space. Then fill upward:

2026 brackets for married filing jointly:

Bracket Taxable income range Tax rate Conversion sweet spot?
10% $0 to $24,800 10% Fill this first
12% $24,801 to $100,800 12% Primary target for most clients
22% $100,801 to $211,400 22% Worth filling if IRMAA allows
24% $211,401 to $403,550 24% Only for high-NW clients with long windows
32% $403,551 to $512,450 32% Rarely worth it

2026 brackets for single filers:

Bracket Taxable income range Tax rate Conversion sweet spot?
10% $0 to $12,400 10% Fill this first
12% $12,401 to $50,400 12% Primary target
22% $50,401 to $105,700 22% Watch IRMAA: $109,000 of MAGI is about $91,000 of taxable income for a single filer 65 or older
24% $105,701 to $201,775 24% Only if warranted

For a married couple under 65 with zero other income, the total conversion in the 12% bracket: $32,200 (standard deduction) + $100,800 (top of 12%) = $133,000 at an average federal rate of about 8.7% ($11,600 of tax). For a couple both 65 or older in 2026 to 2028, the added standard deduction and the senior deduction raise this to about $148,300 ($32,200 + $3,300 + $12,000 + $100,800). That is a large amount moving to tax-free status at a low federal rate. For clients under 65 with Marketplace coverage, add any premium tax credit the conversion costs.

The OBBBA senior deduction: the hidden rate increase

Here’s a planning wrinkle that is easy to miss. The OBBBA created a new deduction for taxpayers 65+: $6,000 per qualifying person ($12,000 for a married couple both 65+). It’s available whether you itemize or take the standard deduction. It lowers taxable income, not AGI, so it does not lower the MAGI that sets IRMAA.

But each person’s $6,000 phases out at 6% of MAGI above $150,000 (MFJ) or $75,000 (single). On a joint return where both spouses qualify, both amounts shrink at once, so the couple loses 12 cents of deduction per dollar of MAGI and the deduction is gone at $250,000 (single filers: $175,000).

What this means in practice (MFJ, both 65+):

MAGI Senior deduction remaining Lost deduction Effective rate in 22% bracket
$150,000 $12,000 (full) $0 22.0%
$175,000 $9,000 $3,000 24.6% (22% + ~2.6% from lost deduction)
$200,000 $6,000 $6,000 24.6%
$225,000 $3,000 $9,000 24.6%
$250,000 $0 (fully phased out) $12,000 Bracket rate only (phaseout complete)

For a couple who both qualify, the phaseout adds about 2.6 percentage points to the marginal rate throughout the $150K-$250K MAGI range (12% combined phaseout rate x 22% tax rate on the lost deduction). In the 24% bracket, the effective addition is about 2.9 points. A single filer, or a couple with only one spouse 65+, loses 6 cents per dollar instead: about 1.3 points at 22% and 1.4 points at 24%.

This may not sound dramatic, but a couple whose conversions carry MAGI through the whole range loses the full $12,000 deduction: $2,640-$2,880 a year in additional taxes they weren’t planning for (at 22% or 24%), or up to about $7,900-$8,600 across 2026-2028. More importantly, it may shift the optimal conversion amount for clients near the $150,000 or $250,000 thresholds.

This deduction is temporary (2025-2028 only). With 2025 closed, three conversion years remain: 2026, 2027 and 2028. For clients 65+ in 2026, 2027 or 2028, conversion sizing requires extra precision. For clients turning 65 after 2028, this doesn’t apply.

Advisor takeaway: For clients 65+ with MAGI between $150K-$250K (MFJ) or $75K-$175K (single) during 2026-2028, factor the senior deduction phaseout into your conversion sizing. The effective marginal rate is about 1.3 to 2.9 points higher than the bracket suggests. Run the numbers with and without the deduction to see the true cost.

IRMAA Bracket Management: The Hidden Cost in Conversion Planning

IRMAA (Income-Related Monthly Adjustment Amount) is a Medicare surcharge based on modified adjusted gross income from two years prior. Roth conversions count as income for IRMAA purposes, and the brackets are cliffs, not graduated: crossing a threshold by even $1 triggers the full surcharge for the entire year. For those age 63+ who will have Medicare at age 65+, this is an important consideration. This also makes Roth conversions before age 63 all the more valuable.

2026 IRMAA brackets (based on 2024 income):

Single Married filing jointly Part B premium (monthly, per person) Part D surcharge (monthly, per person) Annual cost increase (couple)
Up to $109,000 Up to $218,000 $202.90 (standard) $0.00 $0
$109,001-$137,000 $218,001-$274,000 $284.10 $14.50 $2,297
$137,001-$171,000 $274,001-$342,000 $405.80 $37.50 $5,770
$171,001-$205,000 $342,001-$410,000 $527.50 $60.40 $9,240
$205,001-$499,999 $410,001-$749,999 $649.20 $83.30 $12,710
$500,000+ $750,000+ $689.90 $91.00 $13,872

The “Annual cost increase (couple)” column is what matters for planning. Going from the standard tier to the first surcharge tier costs a married couple $2,297 per year in additional premiums. A one-time conversion raises MAGI for one year, so it raises premiums for one year: the premium year two years after the conversion.

The IRMAA planning sequence:

  1. Determine the client’s base MAGI without conversions (Social Security, pension, investment income)
  2. Identify which IRMAA tier they fall in
  3. Calculate the maximum conversion that keeps them in the current tier
  4. Compare the tax savings from converting MORE (and accepting the IRMAA hit) versus converting LESS (and staying below the cliff)

When to accept the IRMAA cost: If the conversion is large enough and the client is young enough, the long-term tax-free growth can outweigh the IRMAA surcharge. A $200,000 conversion that triggers $2,297 in IRMAA costs is worth it if the projected future tax it avoids exceeds the tax paid on it now by more than $2,297. If the projected future tax exceeds today’s tax by only $2,000, it is not.

Advisor takeaway: Calculate the net benefit: the projected future tax avoided on the converted dollars, minus the federal and state tax paid on the conversion now, minus any IRMAA surcharge it triggers. A positive net favors converting; liquidity, estate goals and future tax law still matter. If the net is negative, stay below the cliff. For a deep dive on how every IRMAA tier interacts with conversion sizing, see our Roth conversion and IRMAA planning guide.

How Roth Conversions Are Taxed

Roth conversions are taxed as ordinary income in the year of conversion, at your client’s marginal tax rate. The converted amount is added to all other income, and when possible the tax is best paid from outside funds (not from the converted amount) to keep more money growing tax-free.

Clients need to understand three things:

1. The converted amount is ordinary income.
If a client converts $80,000, that’s $80,000 added to their taxable income. It’s taxed at the marginal rate, not a special capital gains rate.

2. Pay the tax from outside the Roth.
If a client converts $80,000 and uses $18,000 from the conversion to pay the tax, only $62,000 goes into the Roth. Paying the $18,000 from a taxable account instead keeps the full $80,000 growing tax-free. The gain is the tax saved on the outside money’s growth, not its full value: in a hypothetical case of 7% a year for 25 years, with gains in the taxable account taxed at 15%, it is about $12,000 more after tax. When outside funds are available, pay the conversion tax from a taxable brokerage account.

3. The 5-year rule depends on age.
For clients already over 59.5, the conversion penalty rule is moot; they can access converted principal anytime. The 5-year rule on earnings still applies: earnings are not tax-free until a 5-year period has passed, starting January 1 of the first tax year for which the client funded any Roth IRA, by contribution or conversion. This is a good reason to open a small Roth as soon as reasonable.

The conversation that works

Many clients hear “pay tax now” and flinch. Here’s a framing that can help:

“You will pay tax on this money eventually. Right now you’re in the 12% bracket. Our projection shows RMDs could put you in the 22% bracket later. If that happens, every $100,000 we convert now could save about $10,000 in tax on that amount. In a hypothetical 7% growth case, $100,000 in a Roth grows to about $387,000 over 20 years, with no tax on qualified withdrawals.”

Show them two scenarios side by side: total lifetime taxes with conversions vs. without. When clients see the specific dollar difference, the decision is easier to make.

Presenting the Roth Strategy to Clients

Clear presentations share one trait: they make the multi-year math visible in a single view. Not a 40-page report. Not a Monte Carlo histogram. A clear picture of what happens, when, and why.

What works:

  1. Two-scenario comparison. Show the client’s plan with no conversions alongside the recommended strategy. Let them see the cumulative tax difference over 10, 20, and 30 years. The gap between the two lines on a chart is the value of your advice.

  2. Year-by-year timeline. “In 2026 we convert $85,000, in 2027 we convert $90,000…” all the way through. The progression from “mostly pre-tax” to “mostly Roth” is powerful when clients can see it unfold year by year.

  3. Portfolio composition shift. Show the portfolio going from 70% pre-tax / 30% Roth to 30% pre-tax / 70% Roth over the conversion period. Clients understand pie charts. This visualization often gets the biggest reaction.

  4. The expenses view. Show how much they’ll pay in taxes each year under each strategy. The years of higher tax (during conversion) followed by decades of lower tax (after conversion) tells the story clearly. Clients accept short-term cost when they can see the long-term payoff.

Advisor takeaway: The presentation is where the decision gets made. A clear side-by-side comparison makes the multi-year math easier for clients to follow.

Roth Conversion Planning Software: What to Look For

Manual Roth conversion analysis works for a single year. But a 10-year conversion strategy involving tax brackets, IRMAA thresholds, Social Security taxation, state taxes, and now the senior deduction phaseout is not a spreadsheet problem. The interactions between these variables produce results that are often counterintuitive.

What the right tool gives you:

  • Multi-strategy comparison. Run “no conversion” vs “fill 12%” vs “fill 22%” vs “fill 24%” and see total lifetime taxes under each. The strategy with the lowest lifetime tax is often not the one you’d guess.
  • IRMAA cliff modeling. Look for tools that show IRMAA brackets alongside tax brackets, so you can see both cliffs at once.
  • OBBBA senior deduction. This is new for 2025 to 2028. Check how a tool handles it before relying on its 65-and-older projections.
  • Social Security taxation. Conversion income can make up to 85% of Social Security benefits taxable. This interaction can change the best conversion amount by a meaningful margin.
  • Client-ready output. The analysis is only as good as your ability to present it. Look for clear visual comparisons you can walk through in a meeting, not spreadsheet exports.
  • Custodial integration. Pulling account balances from custodians and portfolio platforms lets you run scenarios on current data instead of re-keyed statements.

Income Lab is comprehensive financial planning software for financial advisors, with tax planning built into the client’s plan. Its Tax Lab (Core) compares Roth conversion and withdrawal strategies side by side, including IRMAA bracket strategies, and stars the one with the highest projected net income. Book a demo to see how it works with your client scenarios. For a side-by-side look at planning software, see our comparison of retirement planning software for advisors.

Common Roth Conversion Mistakes

Common Roth conversion mistakes include converting too much in a single year (triggering higher brackets or IRMAA), paying the tax from the IRA itself, and failing to account for the interplay between federal brackets, state taxes, and the new senior deduction.

1. Converting too much in one year.
A client who converts $300,000 in one year instead of $100,000/year for three years pays roughly $26,500 more in federal tax (for a married couple with no other income at 2026 rates, the single-year conversion runs through the 22% bracket and into the 24% bracket instead of staying in the 10% and 12% brackets). Spread the conversions over multiple years to stay in lower brackets.

2. Ignoring IRMAA cliffs.
A $100,000 conversion projected to save a Medicare-age couple $2,000 more in future taxes than it costs in tax now, but that pushes them into the first IRMAA tier, adding $2,297 in surcharges two years later, is a net loss of $297. Always check IRMAA thresholds before sizing the conversion. A $95,000 conversion that stays below the cliff saves more in net terms.

3. Paying the tax from the IRA.
If a client converts $100,000 and withholds $22,000 for taxes, only $78,000 goes into the Roth. Paying the $22,000 from a taxable account instead keeps the full $100,000 growing tax-free; over 25 years at a hypothetical 7%, with gains in the taxable account taxed at 15%, that is worth roughly $14,600 more after tax ($542,743 in the Roth versus $423,340 plus $104,793 after tax outside). For clients under 59.5, the withheld amount is also an early distribution, so it can owe a 10% additional tax. When outside funds are available, use them.

4. Forgetting state taxes.
A client in California pays state income tax of up to 13.3% on top of federal rates (the top rate applies only above $1 million of income). A $100,000 conversion in the federal 22% bracket typically also lands in California’s 8% or 9.3% bracket, for a combined marginal rate of about 30-31.3%. The same conversion in Florida costs 22%. The optimal conversion amount differs dramatically by state.

5. Ignoring the new senior deduction phaseout.
For 2025-2028, clients 65+ face an effective addition of about 2.6-2.9 percentage points to their marginal rate on MAGI between $150K-$250K (MFJ, both spouses 65+), or 1.3-1.4 points for single filers between $75K-$175K. A couple whose conversions carry MAGI through the full range loses up to $2,640-$2,880 a year, or up to about $7,900-$8,600 over 2026-2028. Small enough to miss, large enough to matter.

6. Not starting early enough.
Every year between retirement and RMDs that passes without conversions is bracket space permanently lost. A client who retires at 62 and doesn’t start converting until 68 has lost 6 years of 10% and 12% bracket space. At $133,000/year in the 12% bracket, that’s $798,000 of conversion capacity gone.

7. Treating it as a one-year decision.
The optimal conversion amount in year 1 depends on the plan for years 2-10. If you convert too aggressively in years 1-3, you may run out of pre-tax balance before the window closes, leaving bracket space unused in years 8-10. Model the full window, not one year at a time.

The Bottom Line

Roth conversions remain one of the highest-value services an advisor can provide, even with TCJA rates now permanent. The case has shifted from “beat the sunset” to “beat your client’s future RMDs, IRMAA cliffs, and Social Security taxation.” That case is just as strong, and the math often favors larger and earlier conversions than many plans assume.

Advisors who do this well tend to share three traits: they start planning the year the client retires, they model the full conversion window (not just this year), and they present the comparison in a format clients can see and feel. The gap between “you have an 83% probability of success” and “here’s exactly how much you can convert this year, what it costs in taxes, and what it saves you over the next 20 years” is the gap between average advice and advice that builds trust for life.

Roth conversion sequencing also works closely with a guardrails-based spending strategy. The tax paid on conversions comes out of the same household resources that fund spending, and a down-market year can be an efficient time to convert because the same tax bill moves more shares into the Roth. Advisors who coordinate both in the same plan give clients clearer guidance on what they can actually spend, not just what they can convert.


Income Lab is comprehensive financial planning software for financial advisors. Its Tax Lab (Core) compares Roth conversion and withdrawal strategies side by side, including IRMAA bracket strategies, with tax projections across the full length of the client’s plan. Book a demo to see it with your client scenarios.

This article is for educational purposes for financial professionals. It is not tax, legal or investment advice for any individual. Examples are hypothetical. Tax, Medicare and health insurance rules change; confirm current figures with the IRS, CMS, SSA and HealthCare.gov before acting.


Continue Reading

Frequently Asked Questions

When is the best time to do a Roth conversion?

For many clients, the most valuable Roth conversion window is during the years between retirement and the start of Required Minimum Distributions (age 73 or 75 depending on birth year). During this gap, earned income is gone, Social Security may not have started, and RMDs haven’t kicked in, often leaving clients in the lowest tax brackets they will see in retirement. Every year that passes without conversions is bracket space permanently lost.

How much should I convert to a Roth IRA each year?

A common starting point is to fill the current tax bracket to its upper limit without spilling into the next bracket or, for clients 63 and older, crossing an IRMAA threshold. For a married couple under 65 with no other income in 2026, the conversion capacity in the 12% bracket alone is approximately $133,000 at an average federal rate of about 8.7%. The best amount varies based on existing income, state taxes, health coverage costs before 65, and the client’s full conversion window.

What is the 5-year rule for Roth conversions?

There are two separate 5-year rules. First, if the Roth owner is under age 59.5, each conversion has its own 5-year clock before the converted funds can be withdrawn penalty-free. Second, there is a 5-year rule on earnings: earnings are not tax-free until a 5-year period has passed, starting January 1 of the first tax year for which the owner funded any Roth IRA, by contribution or conversion. For clients over 59.5, only the earnings rule matters. Opening a small Roth early starts the clock.

How does the OBBBA senior deduction affect Roth conversions?

The OBBBA created a new $6,000 per-person deduction for taxpayers 65+ (2025-2028 only). For a couple both 65 or older whose other income does not already use up their deductions, the extra $12,000 lets $12,000 more be converted each year at a 0% federal rate, up to $36,000 across 2026 to 2028. For couples with other income, the deduction lowers tax on income they already have, and conversions are taxed at their bracket rate. Each spouse’s $6,000 phases out at 6% of MAGI above $150,000 MFJ, so a couple who both qualify loses the full $12,000 by $250,000 of MAGI, adding about 2.6 percentage points to the marginal rate in the 22% bracket while it phases out.

Should I pay Roth conversion taxes from the IRA or outside funds?

When possible, pay the tax from outside the Roth, typically from a taxable brokerage account. If a client converts $100,000 and withholds $22,000 for taxes, only $78,000 goes into the Roth. Paying the $22,000 from a taxable account instead keeps the full $100,000 growing tax-free; over 25 years at a hypothetical 7%, with gains in the taxable account taxed at 15%, that is worth roughly $14,600 more after tax. For clients under 59.5, the withheld amount is also an early distribution that can owe a 10% additional tax.

Justin Fitzpatrick, PhD, CFA, CFP - President and Co-Founder of Income Lab

Justin Fitzpatrick is President and Co-Founder of Income Lab, comprehensive financial planning software used by thousands of financial advisors. He developed Income Lab's risk-based guardrails approach to retirement income after a decade in financial services at Jackson and seven years in academia at MIT, Harvard, and UCLA. His research on adjustment-based planning has been published on Kitces.com, ThinkAdvisor, AdvisorPerspectives, and FinancialPlanning Magazine.

Disclosure: Justin Fitzpatrick is Co-Founder of Income Lab, one of the products discussed in this article.

Ready to see this in action?

Watch how Income Lab helps advisors answer clients' toughest retirement income questions with guardrails-based planning.

Book a Walkthrough Start Free Trial